The Easiest and Most Delicious Homemade Macaroni and Cheese

Homemade Macaroni and Cheese is so much better than the what you get in a box! This easy homemade macaroni and cheese will quickly become a family favorite! It is made with simple, inexpensive cheese (nothing fancy) and is easy to make!

Bowl of homemade macaroni and cheese

What Pasta is Best?

I love my easy homemade macaroni and cheese to have bigger pasta so the sauce has more surface to stick to. My favorite paste to use Barilla’s Cellentani pasta. (not getting paid) They area bit thicker, with a long and twisty shape that the sauce clings too! I cook it, then drain it and set it aside.

You can use any type of pasta. If you want to use classic macaroni noodles that is great!

Note: (Cavatappi pasta is basically the same thing as Cellentani).

Box of cellentani pasta

The Cheese for Easy Homemade Macaroni and Cheese

For the cheese you will use shredded cheddar cheese and American cheese. I prefer mild or medium cheddar cheese, but you can use sharp cheddar as well.

Lets talk about the American cheese. You are going to be shocked to hear what I use. It makes it so cheesy and creamy and is so easy! No shredding/grating and no fancy cheese from the cheese and deli counter! (Thank you The Baker Mama!) I use the Kraft Deli American Cheese Slices!

Now don’t get confused here. These deli slices are not the plastic wrapped slices. They are creamier and a step up from the Kraft cheese slices you are thinking of. These Kraft Deli slices are delicious and make the macaroni and cheese creamy and perfect.

I have tried the American cheese from the deli/cheese counter and have tried these Kraft Deli slices and I prefer the Kraft Deli slices! They are both good and will make a great macaroni and cheese, so if the slices freak you out, get your cheese from the Cheese People at the counter! (I am not getting paid from Kraft)

As for the shredded cheddar cheese, you can use mild, medium, sharp, whatever you like best! You can use orange or white cheddar cheese and orange or white American cheese. It will all taste the same, the color will just be whichever you choose.

Shredded cheese and American cheee slices for homemade macaroni

Making Easy Homemade Macaroni and Cheese

Use a large saucepan or large pot. You will make the sauce then add the cooked pasta in to the sauce.

In a large pot or sauce pan/you will make a roux, which is butter, flour, and milk. Once the roux thickens, add both kinds of cheese.

Season it with salt and pepper and some garlic salt and a pinch of ground mustard. Simple and easy flavor but the perfect compliment to the cheese!

You can adjust the seasonings to taste. I always season it after adding the cheese, because the cheese itself will add flavor to the sauce. So season a little as you go, mixing and tasting, then adding more as needed. You can also add more cheese (either kind) to your liking.

If you find your macaroni is too thick (just add a little milk until it reaches the consistency you like! It will thicken upon standing as it cools.

Hand eating a bowl of homemade macaroni and cheese

This macaroni can be stored in the fridge for up to a week. When reheated, you may need to add more milk to thin it out… and maybe even a bit more cheese!

The Easiest and Most Delicious Homemade Macaroni and Cheese is easy to make and your kids (and all adults) will LOVE it! It is cheesy, creamy and so dang good!

Bowl of homemade macaroni and cheese

If you love this homemade macaroni and cheese try my Grilled Mac N’ Cheese Sandwich! Click HERE for the recipe!

For an easy pasta dish, try my Easy Homemade Alfredo!

If you liked this recipe please take the time to leave a comment and a star rating below! Also, don’t forget to follow me on Pinterest, Facebook and Instagram!



Check out the latest posts from the Butcher’s Wife!



The Easiest and Most Delicious Homemade Macaroni and Cheese

This Macaroni and Cheese is the most delicious and the best macaroni you will ever try!  It is fast to make and is rich, creamy and cheesy!
Prep Time 20 minutes
Cook Time 20 minutes
Servings 6 servings

Ingredients

  • 1 pound pasta, I like to use Barilla Cellentani, cooked and drained
  • 5 tbsp butter
  • 5 tbsp flour
  • 3 cups 2% or whole milk this works best for creamy mac n cheese
  • 1 to 2 tsp salt, seasoned to taste
  • 1/2 tsp garlic salt, to taste
  • 1 pinch onion powder
  • pinch of pepper, or more to taste
  • 2 to 3 cups shredded cheddar cheese *to taste I prefer mild or medium
  • 6 to 7 oz. American Cheese, sliced or shredded, to taste which is 6 or 7 slices of the deli cheese, or weigh shredded cheese…*see notes

Instructions

  • Cook your pasta according to the directions on the package.  Drain and set aside after cooking.
  • In a large skillet or sauce pan (big enough to add the pasta too), over meduim heat, melt your butter, add the flour and whisk together, letting it bubble and cook for a few minutes.
  • Slowly add your milk, whisking it so it is smooth and mixed well.    Let this simmer on medium heat until it has thickened, whisking occasionally. It usually takes mine a good 15 minutes to thicken, sometimes longer.
  • Add your cheeses, let them melt and stir them in, making sure they are melted and mixed fully.  Add more cheese if needed to taste.
  • Season your sauce with the salt, garlic salt and pepper. I always start out with a little of each, adding them a little at a time.  Taste as you go so you don't over-season. 
  • After the sauce is seasoned to your liking, add your pasta (make sure there isn't alot of excess water on it).  Mix well – you will probably need a large spoon at this point to stir it all together.  You can adjust cheese and seasonings again if needed.
  • If your macaroni is too thick, thin it out with a little more milk.
  • Serve immediately and enjoy!
  • This macaroni and cheese can be stored in your fridge for up to a week.  You may need to add some more milk if it is too thick when reheating…and you can always add more cheese too! 

Notes

  1.  You can use any type of pasta that you like. I like to use Barilla’s Cellentani pasta. They area bit thicker, with a long and twisty shape that the sauce clings too! 
  2. You need to use a milk with a higher fat content, so 2% or whole works best to get the thick and creamy sauce.
  3. For the shredded cheddar cheese you can choose if you like mild, or medium, or even sharp cheddar cheese. I prefer a mild or medium cheddar for this macaroni.
  4. For the American Cheese, I have tried the American cheese from the deli/cheese counter and have tried Kraft Deli slices and I prefer the Kraft Deli slices! They are both good and will make a great macaroni and cheese.  Don’t freak out if you are adding slices to the sauce, it all melts the same!  Add as little or as much cheese as you prefer.  Add a little at a time until it reaches your perfect level of cheesiness.  You can always add more after seasoning too!
  5. I add the cheese to my sauce first, then season it after the cheese melts.  You need the cheese in the sauce so you season it right.  The cheese tends to add some flavor and salt to the sauce, so I add the cheese first, then season according to taste.

2 Comments

  1. Does anyone know if this can be frozen then baked to reheat?

    • Beth, The Butcher's Wife

      Hi Janet! I have never tried freezing it and then reheating it… If you try it I would undercook the noodles just a little bit… The cheese may separate a little bit when it’s heated but I could be totally wrong! If you try it let me know how it turns out!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe Rating




*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.